Sunday 2 October 2011

The violin concerto by Aram Khachaturian is not the world's greatest. And the Romanian Radio studios in 1954 were not the world's greatest recording venue, nor the Romanian Radio Orchestra the best orchestra of the time. But the performance recorded in 1954 by the said forces conducted by Niyazi created one of the all-time greatest violin concerto recordings in history. Julian Sitkovetsky plays like one possessed during the public performance. In the annals of violin playing, this is above that of Heifetz, Kreisler, Milstein, Oistrakh, Kogan, Rabin and the other greats. This is truly incredible technique allied to truly incredible passion. One of a kind. Available to date only on either Russian Disc, or Arlecchino (both currently unavailable). Sitkovetsky recorded the concerto again in Moscow two years later, with the composer himself conducting. But the version with Niyazi is the one to have.

Two years after this, Julian Sitkovetsky was diagnosed with lung cancer. Two years after that, he was dead at the age of 32. Not since the early exit of Josef Hassid has violin playing been robbed of such a supreme exponent. On my shelves, his recording of the Khachaturian violin concerto with Niyazi will hold a place of honour. And I'll play it to anyone who questions as to what the violin can really achieve.

3 comments:

Lee said...

You can add Ginette Neveu and Michael Rabin to the list of greats who died very young (below 40).

So, which is the best Sitkovetsky Khachaturian VC mastering? Pristine?

Harry Collier said...

Alas, the only remastering of the Sitkovetsky-Niyazi Khachaturian that I know of is Russian Disc (bad) and Arlecchino (not good). Would that someone creative could get hold of the 1954 Romanian originals (if they still exist).

Lee said...

Pristine has done the Paganini & Sibelius VC. No sign of the Khachaturian - yet!