Wednesday 12 March 2008

Beethoven is not normally one of my preferred composers. But I will always make an exception for his late string quartets; timeless classics that are part of the Bible of the highest ranges of music. Especially, one might think, when played by the Busch Quartet. Listening this evening to the E flat quartet (Op 127) one marvels yet again about how right Busch was in this music. Other quartets may be more brilliant, more virtuoso and with better recorded sound. But Busch is right; he appears to have an uncanny knack of always finding the right tempo. Busch seems to start by identifying the pulse of the music, then fixing the tempo, then the dynamics, in a way that you never have any doubts or questionings as to whether things could be done differently. This pulse and tempo sense holds through to his Schubert playing (the quartets, and the fantasia) and also his performances of the Beethoven and Brahms violin concertos. Finally, in his quartet playing there is absolutely no cult of personality; the four members play as they should, weaving in and out of each others' space. Quite and completely admirable.

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

Harry - so the EMI GROC mastering of these SQs is the best sound that was re-produced? Cheers - Lee

Harry Collier said...

The latest EMI GROC re-mastering is the best so far in my humble opinion. One day someone will produce a more definitive transfer; the GROC has a tendency to over-brightness in the higher registers.

Anonymous said...

Dear Harry,
is this latest EMI GROC remastering of the late quartets by Bush Qt. superior to the previous one on the same label contained in the box Schubert-Beethoven-Mendelssohn by Andrew Walter in 1994? Even to the Pearl edition remastered in 1999 by Roger Beardsley?

Thank you!

Marco

Harry Collier said...

Marco,

Short answer; I ain't sure! My principal comparison was with the Biddulph set, and the new GROC is preferable to that. And I am not a fan of Pearl transfers where there are choices of other sources. My feeling is that anyone who has the 1994 EMI transfers need not invest in the new GROC -- except the new GROC contains Op 130 and Op 133 that the Busch did in America.

Anonymous said...

Thank you very much Harry.

Good job for this blog!

Cheers,

Marco